The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), 2023, is a comprehensive legal framework that replaces the Indian Penal Code (IPC) of 1860, intending to modernize and make the law more accessible to the Indian public.
Section 106 of the BNS focuses on the concept of death caused by negligence, addressing acts that lead to the death of an individual due to carelessness or reckless behavior without the intention to kill.
This section retains the core principles found in Section 304A of the IPC, but it introduces nuanced provisions aimed at addressing the unique aspects of medical negligence and vehicular accidents in India.
Also Read: Section 69 of Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS)
The Legal Framework of Section 106 BNS
Section 106 of the BNS has two major sub-sections:
General Negligence (Subsection 1)
Under this provision, any person who causes death by performing a negligent or rash act, that does not amount to culpable homicide, is held criminally liable.
The punishment can extend up to five years of imprisonment, and the individual may also be subject to fines.
This is similar to Section 304A of the IPC, where the core principle remains that death caused due to negligence, without any malice or intent to cause harm, should be punishable by law.
Medical Negligence
A significant addition to the BNS is the introduction of a provision that specifically targets registered medical practitioners who cause death while performing medical procedures negligently.
Medical professionals are entrusted with the lives of their patients, and their duties come with a higher threshold of care. If their negligent actions result in the death of a patient, they face imprisonment of up to two years and a fine.
This provision is in line with the National Medical Commission Act, 2019, and it further clarifies that the medical practitioner must be registered under the National Medical Register or a State Medical Register to fall within the purview of this clause.
Vehicular Negligence (Subsection 2)
The second part of Section 106 deals specifically with deaths caused by rash or negligent driving.
Road accidents are a significant issue in India, and negligence on the roads often results in fatal accidents.
If a driver causes a death due to reckless driving and then escapes without reporting the incident to the police or a magistrate, they could face imprisonment for up to ten years, along with a fine.
Also Read: Extortion | Section 308 | Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS)
Comparison with Section 304A of the IPC
Section 106 of the BNS is built upon the foundation of Section 304A of the IPC, which has long governed cases of death caused by negligence.
Under the IPC, death by negligence attracts a punishment of up to two years, or a fine, or both. The new provision in the BNS, however, significantly increases the penalties, particularly in cases involving vehicular accidents.
Additionally, by differentiating between general negligence and medical negligence, the BNS recognizes the complexity of medical practice and the need for tailored laws that take into account the special responsibilities of healthcare providers.
This is a positive step toward ensuring that both patients and medical professionals have clear legal guidelines to operate within.
Recent Supreme Court Judgments and Interpretations
The Indian Supreme Court has dealt with numerous cases of death caused by negligence under Section 304A of the IPC, and these rulings will have significant influence on how courts interpret and apply Section 106 of the BNS.
Rajneesh Kumar v. State of Bihar (2023)
In a recent judgment, the Supreme Court dealt with a case involving a fatal road accident caused by a rash driver. The court reaffirmed the principle that negligence leading to death without intention should attract penalties under negligence statutes rather than under more serious charges such as culpable homicide.
However, the court also emphasized the need for stiffer penalties, especially in cases where the accused fails to report the incident or attempts to escape responsibility.
This perspective is clearly reflected in Section 106(2) of the BNS, which imposes a harsher penalty of up to ten years for hit-and-run drivers.
Implications for Medical Practitioners
Section 106 of the BNS introduces a clear distinction between general acts of negligence and those performed by medical professionals.
While the punishment for general negligence can extend to five years, medical professionals are subject to a reduced maximum of two years.
This takes into account the often complex and high-pressure situations in which medical professionals operate.
However, it also serves as a reminder that their actions carry significant weight and responsibility. The legal framework under the BNS ensures that negligence is punished, but it does not unfairly target medical practitioners for honest mistakes.
Vehicular Negligence and Road Safety
Vehicular accidents are one of the leading causes of death in India, and the introduction of a harsher penalty for negligent driving reflects the government’s focus on road safety.
Section 106(2) of the BNS not only penalizes reckless driving but also addresses the issue of hit-and-run cases, where drivers attempt to escape without reporting the accident.
The provision for a ten-year sentence is intended to serve as a deterrent to such behavior, encouraging drivers to act responsibly and ensuring that victims receive timely help.
Final Words
Section 106 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, is a well-rounded provision that addresses various facets of death caused by negligence. By increasing the penalties for negligent actions, particularly in the medical and vehicular sectors, the BNS aims to promote accountability and reduce incidents of negligence in India.
Supreme Court judgments, which have long guided the interpretation of Section 304A of the IPC, will continue to influence how Section 106 is applied.
The inclusion of specific clauses addressing medical practitioners and drivers marks a significant advancement in the Indian legal system, ensuring that negligence, whether by accident or carelessness, is appropriately punished.