A contract of indemnity involves two parties, where one promises to compensate the other for loss. In contrast, a contract of guarantee involves three parties: creditor, principal debtor, and surety, where the surety assures payment if the principal debtor defaults.
In Contract Law, two concepts that often cause confusion due to their apparent similarities are the contract of indemnity and the contract of guarantee. Both are mechanisms designed to provide security or protection against potential losses or liabilities, yet they serve distinct purposes and operate under different legal frameworks.
Knowing the differences between these two types of contracts is crucial for legal practitioners, businesses, and individuals engaging in contractual agreements.
Introduction to Contracts of Indemnity and Guarantee
Contracts of indemnity and guarantee are specialized agreements that address risk allocation in commercial and personal transactions. While both involve a promise to compensate or secure another party against loss or default, their scope, parties involved, and legal consequences differ significantly.
A contract of indemnity is primarily concerned with compensating for loss, whereas a contract of guarantee involves securing the performance of a third party’s obligation. These contracts are governed by specific provisions in statutes like the Indian Contract Act, 1872, and by common law principles in jurisdictions such as the United Kingdom and the United States.
Contract of Indemnity: Definition and Scope
A contract of indemnity is a legal agreement in which one party, known as the indemnifier, promises to compensate another party, known as the indemnified or indemnity holder, for any loss suffered due to a specified event or act.
The primary objective of an indemnity contract is to protect the indemnified party against financial loss arising from a particular contingency.
Legal Definition
Under Section 124 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, a contract of indemnity is defined as:
“A contract by which one party promises to save the other from loss caused to him by the conduct of the promisor himself, or by the conduct of any other person, is called a contract of indemnity.”
This definition highlights that the indemnifier undertakes to make good any loss suffered by the indemnified due to the actions of the indemnifier or a third party. For example, in an insurance contract, the insurer (indemnifier) agrees to compensate the insured (indemnified) for losses due to events like fire, theft, or accidents.
Essential Elements of Contract of Indemnity
#1 Two Parties
A contract of indemnity always involves two distinct parties:
- Indemnifier: The party who makes a promise to compensate for any loss or damage that may be suffered.
- Indemnified (or Indemnitee): The party who is to be protected or compensated against the specified loss.
The relationship between these parties is contractual in nature, where one undertakes the obligation to protect the other from harm or loss.
#2 Loss Protection
The primary objective of a contract of indemnity is to safeguard the indemnified from loss or damage. This element is central and must be clearly defined in the contract. The loss can include:
- Financial losses
- Legal liabilities
- Property damages
- Reputational harm (in some cases)
The indemnity must relate to a specific subject matter, and the scope or nature of the loss to be covered should be expressly or impliedly stated in the agreement.
#3 Cause of Loss
The cause or source of the loss must be identifiable. The loss for which indemnity is promised can arise due to:
- The conduct or default of the indemnifier
- The conduct or act of a third party
- An event or circumstance specified in the contract (e.g., theft, fire, legal action)
However, indemnity typically does not cover losses due to natural wear and tear, negligence of the indemnified, or acts that are expressly excluded in the contract.
#4 Express or Implied Contract
An indemnity agreement can be:
- Express: Clearly stated in words, either written or oral. For example, a written clause in a service agreement stating that one party will compensate the other for any legal claims arising out of service delivery.
- Implied: Arises from the conduct or relationship of the parties, even if not directly stated. Courts can infer such a contract when one party acts in a manner that shows an intent to protect the other against specific losses.
For instance, if someone is asked to act on another’s behalf in a transaction, and a loss arises, the law may imply an indemnity obligation depending on the circumstances.
Example
Suppose A agrees to indemnify B for any losses B incurs due to A’s failure to deliver goods on time. If A delays delivery, causing B to lose a lucrative contract, A is liable to compensate B for the financial loss.
Scope of Contract of Indemnity
The scope of indemnity is limited to the actual loss suffered by the indemnified party. The indemnifier’s liability does not extend beyond the agreed terms, and the indemnified must prove the loss to claim compensation.
Contract of Guarantee: Definition and Scope
A contract of guarantee is a tripartite agreement where one party, known as the surety, guarantees the performance of an obligation or debt owed by a principal debtor to a creditor. If the principal debtor fails to fulfill their obligation, the surety becomes liable to the creditor.
Legal Definition
According to Section 126 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872:
“A contract of guarantee is a contract to perform the promise, or discharge the liability, of a third person in case of his default. The person who gives the guarantee is called the surety; the person in respect of whose default the guarantee is given is called the principal debtor, and the person to whom the guarantee is given is called the creditor.”
This definition underscores the tripartite nature of the contract, involving the surety, principal debtor, and creditor.
Essential Elements of Contract of Guarantee
#1 Three Parties Involved
A contract of guarantee is tripartite in nature, involving three distinct parties:
- Principal Debtor: The person who is primarily responsible for fulfilling the obligation, such as repaying a loan or performing a contractual duty.
- Creditor: The person or entity who extends credit or provides a service or loan, expecting repayment or performance from the principal debtor.
- Surety (Guarantor): The person who assures the creditor that the principal debtor will fulfill their obligation. If the principal debtor defaults, the surety promises to take on the responsibility.
Each of these parties has a unique role and a clear legal relationship with one another.
#2 Primary Liability of the Principal Debtor
The principal debtor bears the primary liability under the main contract. This means:
- The obligation to pay or perform lies directly with the principal debtor.
- The creditor’s primary recourse is to the principal debtor, not the surety.
- The surety only steps in if and when the principal debtor defaults.
Example: If A borrows $10,000 from B and C acts as a surety, A is primarily liable to repay the amount to B.
#3 Secondary Liability of the Surety
The surety’s obligation is secondary and arises only upon default by the principal debtor. This means:
- The surety does not have to fulfill the obligation unless the principal debtor fails to do so.
- The liability of the surety is co-extensive with that of the principal debtor unless specified otherwise in the contract (e.g., limited to a certain amount or time period).
- After paying the creditor, the surety typically has the right to recover the amount from the principal debtor (right of subrogation).
#4 Existence of a Valid Contract
For a contract of guarantee to be enforceable, there must be:
- A valid and enforceable agreement between the principal debtor and the creditor.
- If the primary contract is void or unenforceable (e.g., due to illegality, lack of consent, or fraud), the guarantee may also become unenforceable.
- All essential elements of a valid contract under contract law (such as free consent, lawful object, etc.) must be present.
#5 Consideration
A contract of guarantee must be supported by consideration, which may not necessarily flow to the surety. According to the law:
- It is sufficient if there is some benefit to the principal debtor or some detriment to the creditor.
- Commonly, the consideration is the creditor’s act of extending a loan or credit, or delaying the enforcement of a debt at the surety’s request.
Example: If B agrees to give a loan to A on the condition that C guarantees its repayment, the consideration for C’s guarantee is B’s act of granting the loan.
Example
If C borrows money from D and E guarantees that C will repay the loan, E (the surety) is liable to pay D (the creditor) if C (the principal debtor) defaults.
Scope
The contract of guarantee is contingent on the principal debtor’s default. The surety’s liability is secondary and co-extensive with that of the principal debtor, unless otherwise specified.
Differences Between Contract of Indemnity and Contract of Guarantee
| Basis of Difference | Contract of Indemnity | Contract of Guarantee |
| Definition | A contract to compensate for loss caused by another’s act | A contract to perform or discharge a third person’s liability |
| Governing Sections | Sections 124–125 of the Indian Contract Act | Sections 126–147 of the Indian Contract Act |
| Number of Parties | Two (Indemnifier and Indemnified) | Three (Creditor, Principal Debtor, Surety) |
| Nature of Liability | Primary | Secondary |
| Arises When | Loss is suffered by the indemnified | Default by the principal debtor |
| Purpose | To protect against loss | To assure performance or repayment |
| Consideration | For benefit to indemnified or detriment to indemnifier | Benefit to principal debtor or act by creditor |
| Right Against Third Party | No such right unless assigned | Surety gains creditor’s rights against principal debtor (subrogation) |
| Surety Element | No surety involved | Surety undertakes obligation |
| Involvement of Debtor | No third-party debtor required | Requires a principal debtor |
| Right of Reimbursement | Indemnifier reimburses for loss directly | Surety reimburses creditor and is reimbursed by principal debtor |
| Form of Contract | Usually written, may be implied | May be oral or written |
| Legal Action | Indemnified can sue only after loss | Creditor can sue surety upon default |
| Scope of Protection | Covers only actual loss | Covers future liability if default occurs |
| Type of Security | No security is usually involved | Surety acts as security |
| Revocation | Indemnity contracts not revoked unless mutually agreed | Continuing guarantee can be revoked for future transactions |
| Liability Extent | Covers full loss or damage | Co-extensive with principal debtor unless limited |
| Example | Insurance contract | Loan guarantee |
| Death Effect | May not end unless personal in nature | Death of surety ends future liability unless stated otherwise |
| Involves Series of Transactions | Typically covers single events or losses | May be continuing for multiple transactions |
While both contracts aim to provide security, their legal and practical implications differ significantly. Below is a detailed comparison based on various parameters:
Number of Parties
- Indemnity: Involves two parties, the indemnifier and the indemnified.
- Guarantee: Involves three parties, the surety, principal debtor, and creditor.
Nature of Liability
- Indemnity: The indemnifier’s liability is primary. They are directly responsible for compensating the indemnified for any loss.
- Guarantee: The surety’s liability is secondary. The surety is liable only if the principal debtor fails to perform their obligation.
Purpose
- Indemnity: The purpose is to compensate for loss caused by specific events or actions, regardless of who caused the loss.
- Guarantee: The purpose is to secure the performance of a third party’s obligation, ensuring the creditor is protected against the principal debtor’s default.
Underlying Contract
- Indemnity: Does not require an underlying contract between the indemnified and a third party. The indemnity contract stands alone.
- Guarantee: Requires an underlying contract or obligation between the principal debtor and the creditor, which the surety guarantees.
Consideration
- Indemnity: Consideration may or may not be explicitly stated, as the promise to indemnify itself can be sufficient consideration.
- Guarantee: Requires consideration, typically the creditor’s agreement to extend credit or provide a benefit to the principal debtor.
Extent of Liability
-
Indemnity: The indemnifier’s liability is limited to the actual loss suffered by the indemnified, as per the contract terms.
-
Guarantee: The surety’s liability is co-extensive with the principal debtor’s liability, unless the contract specifies otherwise (Section 128, Indian Contract Act, 1872).
Rights of the Parties
- Indemnity: The indemnified has the right to claim compensation for losses directly from the indemnifier. The indemnifier has no right to recover from a third party unless specified.
- Guarantee: The surety, upon discharging the principal debtor’s liability, gains the right to recover the amount from the principal debtor (subrogation rights under Section 140, Indian Contract Act, 1872).
Termination
- Indemnity: The contract terminates once the indemnified is compensated for the loss or the specified event does not occur.
- Guarantee: The contract may continue until the principal debtor’s obligation is fulfilled or the guarantee is revoked (subject to limitations under Section 130, Indian Contract Act, 1872).
Examples in Practice
- Indemnity: Insurance contracts, where the insurer indemnifies the insured against losses from fire, theft, or other perils.
- Guarantee: A bank guarantee, where a bank (surety) assures a supplier (creditor) that a buyer (principal debtor) will make payment.
Legal Provisions Governing Contract of Indemnity and Guarantee
Contract of Indemnity (Sections 124–125)
A contract of indemnity is a contract by which one party promises to save the other from loss caused to him by the conduct of the promisor himself or by the conduct of any other person.
Example: A promises to indemnify B if B suffers any loss as a result of acting on A’s instructions in a transaction.
Essential Features
- Parties Involved: Two parties – the indemnifier (the one who promises to compensate) and the indemnified (the one who is protected).
- Purpose: To protect the indemnified from losses.
- Trigger of Liability: Liability arises only when the indemnified suffers a loss.
- Nature of Contract: May be express or implied, but must be based on a legal obligation.
Rights of the Indemnified (Section 125)
The indemnified can recover:
- All damages he is compelled to pay in a suit related to the indemnity.
- All legal costs incurred in defending or settling such a suit.
- Any amount paid under a compromise, provided it was not contrary to the indemnifier’s instructions and was reasonable.
Contract of Guarantee (Sections 126–147)
A contract of guarantee is a contract to perform the promise or discharge the liability of a third person in case of his default.
Example: A lends money to B. C guarantees repayment. If B fails to repay, C is liable to pay.
Essential Features
- Parties Involved: Three parties – the principal debtor, the creditor, and the surety (guarantor).
- Type of Liability: The surety’s liability is secondary and arises only when the principal debtor defaults.
- Form: Can be oral or written.
- Consideration: Any benefit to the principal debtor or detriment to the creditor is sufficient consideration for the guarantee.
Key Provisions
- Section 127: Valid consideration is any benefit to the principal debtor or act done by the creditor.
- Section 128: The liability of the surety is co-extensive with that of the principal debtor unless otherwise stated.
- Section 129: A continuing guarantee applies to a series of transactions.
- Section 130: A continuing guarantee can be revoked at any time for future transactions by giving notice to the creditor.
- Section 131: Death of the surety revokes the continuing guarantee for future transactions, unless otherwise agreed.
- Sections 133–136: A surety is discharged from liability if:
-
- The terms of the contract between the creditor and principal debtor are varied without the surety’s consent.
- The creditor releases the principal debtor.
- The creditor acts in a way that impairs the surety’s eventual remedy against the principal debtor.
-
- Section 140: The surety has the right of subrogation – after paying the debt, he is entitled to all the rights the creditor had against the principal debtor.
- Section 145: The surety is entitled to be indemnified by the principal debtor for all lawful payments made under the guarantee.
Rights and Obligations of Parties under Contracts of Indemnity and Guarantee
Contract of Indemnity
Parties Involved
- Indemnifier: The person who promises to compensate for the loss.
- Indemnified (Indemnitee): The person who is protected against loss.
Rights of the Indemnified
Under Section 125, the indemnified is entitled to recover from the indemnifier:
- All damages which he may be compelled to pay in any suit related to the indemnity.
- All costs reasonably incurred in defending or settling such a suit, provided the indemnifier authorized it or the circumstances justified it.
- All amounts paid under a lawful settlement, provided it was not contrary to the indemnifier’s directions.
Obligations of the Indemnifier
- To compensate the indemnified for any actual loss or damage incurred due to the conduct specified in the contract.
- To make payment or reimbursement without unnecessary delay once loss is suffered.
- To act in good faith if the indemnity involves legal claims or third-party rights.
Obligations of the Indemnified
- To act reasonably in incurring costs or settlements.
- To follow directions from the indemnifier, where applicable.
- To avoid unnecessary loss or damage and mitigate losses when possible.
Contract of Guarantee
Parties Involved
- Principal Debtor: The person whose obligation is guaranteed.
- Creditor: The person who is owed performance or repayment.
- Surety (Guarantor): The person who undertakes to pay or perform if the principal debtor defaults.
Rights of the Surety
- Right of Subrogation (Section 140): After discharging the liability, the surety steps into the shoes of the creditor and can exercise all rights against the principal debtor.
- Right to Indemnity (Section 145): The surety can recover from the principal debtor all amounts lawfully paid under the guarantee.
- Right to Benefit of Securities (Section 141): The surety is entitled to benefit from any security held by the creditor against the principal debtor.
- Right to be Discharged: The surety may be discharged from liability if:
-
- The creditor varies the terms of the contract without the surety’s consent.
- The creditor releases the principal debtor.
- The creditor impairs the surety’s eventual remedy.
-
Obligations of the Surety
- To fulfill the liability when the principal debtor defaults, subject to the terms of the guarantee.
- To pay the amount or perform the obligation as agreed in the contract of guarantee.
- To act by any limitations set out in the guarantee (such as time, amount, or scope).
Rights of the Creditor
- To demand performance or payment from the surety upon the principal debtor’s default.
- To sue the surety directly without first proceeding against the principal debtor (unless otherwise agreed).
- To enforce any security or collateral attached to the transaction.
Obligations of the Creditor
- Not to alter the terms of the contract with the principal debtor without the surety’s consent.
- Not to release the principal debtor or impair securities, as such actions may discharge the surety.
- To act fairly and in good faith concerning all parties.
Obligations of the Principal Debtor
- To fulfill the original obligation as per the contract with the creditor.
- To indemnify the surety if the surety makes payment on their behalf.
- To avoid conduct that increases the surety’s risk without proper consent.
Bottom Line
A contract of indemnity is a legal agreement between two parties where one party, called the indemnifier, promises to compensate the other party, known as the indemnified, for any loss or damage caused by the indemnifier’s actions or those of a third party. The primary purpose of this contract is to protect the indemnified from financial loss. The indemnifier’s liability arises only when the indemnified suffers an actual loss. This contract usually involves situations like insurance policies, where one party agrees to cover the losses incurred by another.
In contrast, a contract of guarantee involves three parties: the creditor, the principal debtor, and the surety or guarantor. The surety agrees to fulfill the obligation or pay the debt if the principal debtor fails to do so. The key feature of this contract is that the surety’s liability is secondary and arises only upon the default of the principal debtor. Guarantee contracts are common in loan agreements, where a third party guarantees repayment to the lender if the borrower defaults.
The essential differences lie in the number of parties involved, the nature of liability, and when the liability arises. Indemnity contracts involve two parties with primary liability on the indemnifier, triggered by actual loss. Guarantee contracts involve three parties with secondary liability on the surety, triggered by the principal debtor’s default.
Both contracts require valid consideration and must be entered into with genuine consent to be enforceable under the law. Knowing their distinct features helps in choosing the right legal instrument for protecting financial interests effectively.
Follow The Legal QnA For More Updates…
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
What is the difference between a contract of indemnity and contract of guarantee?
A contract of indemnity involves two parties where one compensates the other for loss. A contract of guarantee involves three parties, where the surety assures payment if the principal debtor defaults.
What is the difference between indemnify and guarantee?
To indemnify means to compensate for loss or damage. To guarantee means to assure performance or payment if another party defaults.
What is the difference between a contract and an indemnity?
A contract is a broader agreement creating enforceable obligations. A contract of indemnity is a specific contract where one party promises to compensate for loss.
What is a contract of indemnity with an example?
A contract of indemnity is where one party promises to compensate another for loss. Example: An insurance policy where insurer indemnifies the insured against damage.
What is a contract of guarantee?
A contract where a third party (surety) promises to fulfill the obligation if the principal debtor fails to perform.
What is the difference between indemnity and warranty?
Indemnity compensates for loss after it occurs. Warranty is a promise that certain facts or conditions are true, and breach allows claim for damages.
What is the difference between a contract of indemnity and a contingent contract?
Indemnity contracts involve compensation for actual loss. Contingent contracts depend on the occurrence of an uncertain event.
What is the difference between a guarantee and a warranty?
Guarantee involves a third party assuring performance. Warranty is a promise made by a seller about the quality or condition of goods.
What is the difference between indemnity and surety?
Indemnity involves primary liability to compensate for loss. Surety involves secondary liability to pay if the principal debtor defaults.
What is the difference between a contract of insurance and a guarantee?
Insurance is a contract of indemnity protecting against loss. Guarantee is a contract ensuring performance or payment by a third party.
What is the difference between indemnity and damages?
Indemnity is compensation agreed in advance for loss. Damages are compensation awarded by a court for breach of contract.
What is the concept of indemnity?
Indemnity is a promise to protect a party from loss or damage, reimbursing them if loss occurs.
What is Section 125 of the Contract Act?
Section 125 provides the indemnified the right to recover damages, costs, and amounts paid under compromise from the indemnifier.
What is the difference between indemnity and guarantee in PPT?
In presentations, indemnity shows two parties and primary liability; guarantee shows three parties and secondary liability with surety.
What is the difference between indemnity and breach of contract?
Indemnity is compensation for loss. Breach of contract is failure to perform agreed terms, which may lead to damages.
What is an example of indemnity contract?
An insurance contract where the insurer agrees to compensate for loss or damage to insured property.
Who are Bailee and Bailor?
The bailor is the person who delivers goods for safekeeping. The bailee is the person who receives goods and is responsible for them.
What is the difference between warranty and indemnity?
Warranty is a promise about product quality; indemnity is a promise to compensate for loss.
What is the difference between indemnity contract and contingent contract?
Indemnity contract requires compensation for actual loss. Contingent contract depends on an uncertain event happening.